Did we really pay that invoice twice?
The payment list can show the same invoice twice for several reasons. The amount worth reporting depends on what actually left the bank, what it paid for and how much the supplier returned.
Ask three questions before reporting an overpayment
Did the money leave twice?
A spreadsheet can list one payment twice. Check the bank statement for two separate payments.
What did each payment cover?
The second payment may belong to another invoice. Ask the supplier which bill each payment covered.
How much is still owed back?
Someone may have marked the payment as reversed in the accounts. Check whether the refund reached the bank or the supplier used the amount to settle another bill.
Where AI helps
AI can spot a possible repeat and suggest what to check first. Ask it, “What else could explain this, and what would settle it?” That gives the auditor a short list of checks before reporting an overpayment.
Once you confirm a duplicate, ask how it got through. Getting this payment back recovers the money. Finding out how it was approved helps prevent the next one.